It's one of the most common questions in diabetes clinics in Malaysia: "I've stopped white sugar and use honey now. That's better, right?" Or gula Melaka, or brown sugar, or palm sugar, or raw cane sugar. They're often sold as natural or healthier, and they feel like a sensible swap.

Unfortunately, for your blood sugar, they're much more alike than different. This article explains why, and what actually helps.

In short

  • Honey, gula Melaka, brown sugar and white sugar are all mostly sugar, and all of them raise your blood sugar.
  • Small differences in vitamins or minerals don't make them meaningfully healthier in normal amounts.
  • The real win is using less sugar of any kind, and letting your taste buds adjust.

What each one is

  • White sugar is refined sucrose from sugar cane or sugar beet: about 100 percent sugar.
  • Brown sugar is white sugar with some molasses added back, or less refined sugar. It's still almost entirely sugar, with a trace of minerals.
  • Gula Melaka (palm sugar) is made by boiling down the sap of coconut or other palms. It's mostly sucrose, with small amounts of glucose and fructose, and a few minerals.
  • Honey is made by bees from flower nectar. It's mostly fructose and glucose, with a little water. Gram for gram it has slightly fewer calories than sugar because of the water, but a spoonful of honey is heavier than a spoonful of sugar, so it often ends up similar.
  • Kurma (dates) syrup, agave and maple syrup are also concentrated sugars, however natural they sound.

What they do to your blood sugar

Your body breaks all of these down into glucose and fructose. Some, like honey and gula Melaka, may raise blood sugar slightly more slowly than white sugar in laboratory tests, but the difference is small, and it disappears when you use a bit more because it's "healthy". A tablespoon of honey in your tea raises your blood sugar in much the same way as a tablespoon of sugar.

The minerals and antioxidants in honey or gula Melaka are real but tiny. You'd need to eat far too much sugar to get any meaningful benefit, and you'd get far more from vegetables, fruit, nuts and beans.

What helps instead

  1. Use less, gradually. Halve the sugar in your drinks and recipes over a few weeks. Your taste for sweetness adjusts, and soon full-sugar drinks taste too sweet.
  2. Choose kosong or kurang manis at stalls and restaurants.
  3. Use spices for flavour: cinnamon, cardamom, pandan, ginger and vanilla make food and drinks taste sweeter without sugar.
  4. Consider sweeteners if you need them. Sweeteners such as stevia, sucralose and aspartame don't raise blood sugar. They can help while you cut down, but the long-term aim is to need less sweetness overall.
  5. Eat whole fruit for something sweet, in fist-sized portions, rather than adding sugar or honey.
  6. Read labels. Sugar hides under many names: sucrose, glucose, fructose, syrup, honey, malt and more.

Hidden sugar in Malaysian cooking

Sugar doesn't only come from the sugar bowl. Kicap manis, sweet chilli sauce, oyster sauce, satay peanut sauce, sambal and many curry pastes contain added sugar, and some recipes call for a spoonful of gula Melaka or sugar to balance the flavour. When you cook, try halving the sugar in the recipe. At stalls, ask for sauces on the side so you can use less.

When sugar is the right choice

If you take insulin or tablets such as gliclazide and your blood sugar drops below 4.0 mmol/L, fast-acting sugar is exactly what you need. Three teaspoons of sugar or honey in water, half a glass of a regular soft drink, or glucose tablets will bring it up quickly. Check again after 15 minutes.

Try this

  1. Look at how you sweeten your drinks and cooking at home.
  2. This week, cut the amount of sugar, honey or gula Melaka by a quarter.
  3. Next week, cut it by another quarter, and try adding cinnamon or pandan for flavour.
  4. Notice when your old drinks start to taste too sweet. That's your taste buds changing.

Common questions

Is honey better than sugar for diabetes?

Not in any meaningful way. Honey is mostly sugar and raises blood sugar in much the same way as white sugar. Use small amounts of either, or a sweetener.

Is gula Melaka healthy for diabetics?

Gula Melaka is still mostly sugar. It contains small amounts of minerals, but it raises blood sugar like other sugars, so keep it to small amounts in occasional desserts.

What sweetener is safe for diabetes?

Sweeteners such as stevia, sucralose and aspartame don't raise blood sugar and are considered safe in normal amounts. They can help while you cut down on sugar.

Stay safe

If you have a low sugar reading, don't wait for a "healthy" option. Treat it straight away with fast sugar, check again after 15 minutes, and tell your doctor about any lows. In an emergency, go to the nearest Emergency Department or call 999.


Please note: this article is general health education for adults in Malaysia. It doesn't replace advice from your own doctor or dietitian.